Two things you could do to optimize that MS-Blues Harp: Take a small file and round off the edges of the comb tines for greater playing comfort. The venerable Marine Band Classic, Hohner's best selling diatonic for more than a century, has undergone many changes over its history, which I've documented on this page. But Hohner revamped the design about three years in (circa 1995) and made them actually quite robust. As such getting the best harmonica in the market is important. In the end i just prefer the sound of a wooden reed over plastic. Once again a triple lacquered comb, but where the original Deluxe was sealed just on the outsides edges and in the reed chambers, the current version has all surfaces of the comb sealed. Press J to jump to the feed. Enjoy your harmonica journeys. Crossover vs. Deluxe. Offline . Top. I’m looking to get back into playing the harmonica in a band situation, and I need some new performance harps. Hohner Blues Harp vs. Golden Melody. Les meilleures offres pour Vintage Hohner Marine Band Box W/ Hohner "Blues Harp" Harmonica Instrument sont sur eBay Comparez les prix et les spécificités des produits neufs et d'occasion Pleins d'articles en livraison gratuite! In the key of C they both feel very responsive and fun to play, they are the best bang for the buck, and they will last a very long time. The additions and improvements to the Marine Band range (including the regular Marine Band, the Deluxe, the Crossover and the Thunderbird) are due in no small part to the tireless enthusiasm and hard work of Steve Baker, who has made the Marine Band his own pet project. I've been playing this harp for a while now and not noticed any changes in the comb, although I tend to play with a relatively dry mouth anyway, so your mileage may vary. The instrument in question is the Marine Band 1896 Classic, the original blues harmonica and historically the world's most popular harmonica. The MS harps got a bad rap early on because the original reed design was poor. I decided that the Blues Harps had weak reeds, and switched to a plastic-bodied Hohner. The tuning is rooted somewhere between A=443 and A=445, using a light temperament, with 5 and 9 draw tuned sharper than the MB Classic, but not quite as sharp as on the MS harps. The most recent improvement to the Blues Harp MS is, as with the Marine Band Classic, a triple lacquered comb, again on all surfaces of the wood (the wood being the tropical hardwood Doussie, used on previous version of the Blues Harp MS). The blues harp and Marine Band are tuned differently. Joined: 05/08/2010 . 4,7 sur 5 étoiles 140. Here’s how I compare them. Two things you could do to optimize that MS-Blues Harp: Take a small file and round off the edges of the comb tines for greater playing comfort. If you see saw marks, flat sanding the comb could improve airtightness. Hohner Marine Band – Pros: How it plays: What I liked about the Marine Band from the beginning was that it really felt like a music instrument when you draw and blow air through it. The MS-Blues Harp comb is made of Doussie, a wood that is less swell-prone than the pearwood used in Marine Bands (which nowadays are sealed and less prone to swelling, though it still happens in my experience), and also has mild antibacterial properties. Joined: 06/03/2011 . When investigating a single manufacturer, you might still vacillate over Hohner blues harp vs marine band harmonicas. Also, the lacquer on this one looks shinier and feel slicker than on the MB Classic and the Blues Harp MS. Le Marine Band de chez Hohner est finalement assez proche du Blues Harp bien qu'un peu moins chaleureux et non équipé du système Modular System. It produces the great tone that old-style Marine Band players are used to, but it offers even more versatility. The reeds are identical to those used on the MB Classic, MB Crossover, Special 20 and Golden Melody and I think this is a great harp for the player who likes the traditional Marine Band style harmonica, but prefers reedplates that are attached with screws, rather than nails. When did the MS series come out? Hohner Marine Band Harmonicas are the gold standard of blues harmonica. Hohner had have quite a bit of competition over the last few years, but it seems that they have responded by stepping up their game. Just listen to any Sonny Boy (1 & 2), Little Walter, George Smith, Paul Butterfield, or William Clarke recordings, just to name too few. I just discovered. The valves rattle like crazy and it makes a noise that makes me sick..and that’s what I’ve heard is supposed to be one of the better off brand harps. Hohner Marine Band Harmonica 5-Pack in a padded case: The same thing as above in a traditional wooden-comb harmonica. You sound like a knowledgeable guy . I just googled and you can get a Pyle for $16. The most recent change is that it now has a triple lacquered comb to help reduce moisture-related problems. I’d love to hear your stuff . The Harmonica is among the easiest musical instruments to learn how to play. Le Sommier est en bois. For any given reed on a Marine Band or Progressive series, the MS reed will be longer, giving it a somewhat bigger sound. In this video I compare 3 different harmonicas that all carry the Hohner Marine Band harmonica name. 12TET will enhance the brighter attributes of the harmonica. COVER PLATES In 1973 I purchased my first Hohner “Blues Harp”. I used to be a German only player too (I have roughly 50 harps and most are either honer or lee Oskar a few Suzuki all aluminum )and the Pyle (American made ) sounds better than the blues harp bluesband or the marine band . Many people opt for it as a learning instrument due to its simplicity. Its uniquely authentic sound has defined the role of the harmonica in the blues tradition and made it the benchmark harp by which all others are judged. It responds very well and very fast to your breathing and has a great push and “voice projection”. I would like to play a special 20, i’ll buy it in A and post to let you know how it is. Par contre il est du coup un peu plus polyvalent. The tuning on the sample I have is a little closer to Just Intonation than previous MS models that I've examined, but with 5 and 9 draw tuned significantly sharper than the Classic models and the whole harp tuned slightly higher overall - keynotes relative to A=444Hz. With its trademark vented cover plates adorned with ornate stampings, wooden combs and outstanding reed sets -- the traditional voicing of this harmonica is unmistakable. Anytime I hear the word "cheap" in a conversation about harps, I take interest. Aside from this, the harp is pretty much the same as it's been over the past decade or so, although I did notice that tuning and reed adjustment was a little more consistent on my review sample than on the last batch of MBs I had the chance to examine. As far as my researches showed me, the Blues Harp is basically the same harmonica as the Marine Band but in a more robust metal package. I also notice that there are no reedplate codes stamped on the sample I have. Big Names in the Harmonica Industry. Any vids? Invest those few extra bucks and get a Hohner Marine Band or a Hohner Blues Harp instead. I own a Special 20 and several Marine Bands (as well as some Golden Melodys). Click here for our system of mastery for all skill level blues harmonica students. The sample I have is in Bb and plays comparably with some of my better vintage Marine Bands. This was the starting point of our Marine Band Series, which has gone on to play a key role in unleashing the raw emotion of the blues, the free spirit of country or the energy of rock ’n’ roll. It is handmade in Germany, and you can pretty much say that it’s a jacked up version of the beloved, #1 best-selling Hohner model – the Marine Band. Sorry, this post was deleted by the person who originally posted it. MBD tuning is the same as current marine band 1896. Most significant is that the Marine Band is a wooden comb, nails-in-wood construction whereas the Blues Harp is a sealed wooden comb with screw mount construction. For the record, the blow chord is rooted relative to A=443Hz, with the draw chord a little higher. If you were one of the many people who was disappointed with the MS harps when they first came out, you might want to try some of the recent production runs - the tone and response is not quite the same as on the Classic Series, but if this one is representative of the current state of the MS harp, then they are solid workhorse instruments, immeasurably better than those first MS models. There’s different styles throughout the US, the UK has its own blues scene, and Irish folk has bluesy influences as well – or does blues have Irish influences? It's great to see this old favorite back on form again! It also has a sealed comb and a new cover style, making it as airtight and sturdy as possible. From the classic 1896 to the modern Crossover, the Marine Band Series offers a range of genre-defining instruments which are the choice for countless leading harmonica artists today. Do you have a specific model name/# you would recommend? Forums:: Gear. It received very good reviews when it first came out in 2005, but Hohner have found a few ways to make them even better. The current version of the Blues Harp is part of Hohner's Modular Series and was introduced in the 1990s. The most recent improvement to the Blues Harp MS is, as with the Marine Band Classic, a triple lacquered comb, again on all surfaces of the wood (the wood being the tropical hardwood Doussie, used on previous version of the Blues Harp MS… None of these are new models, of course, but they have all undergone recent changes, so I thought brief reviews of the current versions were in order. The … Nope call Pyle acoustic customer and ask em . The bends are all easy to play right out of the box and the 4, 5 and 6 overblows are there without any adjustment. The Deluxe also comes in a neat zippered case like the Crossover and Thunderbird. The thirds on the Blues Harp, for instance, are a bit sharper and the chords aren't as lively, you don't hear that interaction of the tones like you do on a Marine Band, unless you retune it. What's the difference besides the bamboo comb? Cafe Society. It does feel like it, but the bigger and more robust case does give it a more solid feel in your hands – which I believe just makes the harmonica more satisfying and … The lacquer is applied to all surfaces of the pear wood comb and you can easily tell these apart from the older models by their natural finish, rather than the time-honoured yellow paint on the outside edges of the comb. It’s a more raw blues sound. 28,00 € 28,00 € "harmonica chromatique" OTraki Harmonica en Do 10 Trous 40 Tonnes Clés de C Blues Harpe Harmonica Professionnel Musique à Bouche avec Étui et Chiffon de Nettoyage pour Débutants Enfants Adultes Étudiant Cadeau. 4,5 sur 5 étoiles 294. Speaking of comfort, the Deluxe now features the same ergonomic cover shape as the recent version of the Crossover, with no more gaps to snag the facial hair of moustachioed players! New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Note: I am not endorsed by any specific harmonica company. 3 replies Sat, 08/25/2012 - 09:34 Taylor Ward . The current version of the Blues Harp is part of Hohner's Modular Series and was introduced in the 1990s. And unlike the “compromised just tuning” of the Marine Band (better for chordal playing), the Crossover is tuned closer to 12TET “12 tone equal temperament” (better for single note playing) – think Hohner Golden Melody or Lee Oskar harmonicas. Check the comb surfaces where the reedplates lie on them. I highly recommend either the Marine Band or the Blues Harp / Pro Harp as a first harmonica. Honer player for 30 years . The Hohner Marine Band Deluxe puts a modern spin on Hohner's popular Classic Marine Band harp. All the best,-Alon. Well put together for the price . As David’s answer says, one difference is the comb material, plastic versus pearwood. A community for all harmonica players and enthusiasts. Pyle harps . For any given reed on a Marine Band or Progressive series, the MS reed will be longer, giving it a somewhat bigger sound. I find with the blues harps they require more air than the marine. I practice on Marine Bands, but have always used Blues Harps live and when recording due to the fact that they’re easier to play when I’m drunk and I like their dirtier sound. Whichever came first, blues is known and loved around the globe. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. They don't leak as much air. Whether you play diatonic, chromatic, tremelo, bass, or chord harps - or you lip purse, tongue block, or u-block, welcome! Looking at some pictures online and I'm 90% confident that Pyle are rebadged East Tops. If you are new to the world of harmonicas you might find it challenging to determine what the best harmonica is for your situation, which manufacturer is best, or which type of harmonica you need to use. You can feel the brass reeds vibrating deep inside it. Dave Hall . Mon, 08/27/2012 - 18:29 #1. black_rabbit April 3, 2002, 1:07am #1. That Lee Oskar Harmonica vs Hohner Special 20. With the Blues Band, you can join the fun, play along to your favorites, or jam with friends. These reviews are strictly based on my own experience and opinions. Although I applaud all the innovation Hohner has done in the past few years, I can't help but feel their hand was forced by all the innovation that Seydel and Suzuki have done in the past 5-10. Right now I play a Hohner Blues harp and I love it but it doesn’t compare to the marine band. "harmonica hohner blues harp" Hohner Harmonica Blues Harp en la majeur. C, G, D, A, E: Hohner "Case of Blues" Harmonica 5-Pack in a zippered case: A relatively economical way to get started on a Blues Harp collection. Offline . The original version of the Blues Harp was introduced in the late 1960s and despite the stories about the reeds somehow being different (see this page for more details), was essentially a Marine Band with different covers. Idk I tried cheaping out in a easttop and I was terribly disappointed with their half valved harps. Blues is an incredibly versatile and eclectic genre. Great CHEAP(price) harp . Maybe I should have just went with non valved to be fair but I don’t want another non German made one right now I guess. Combined with the rounded ends to the comb tines, this gives a really comfortable playing surface to the mouth and tongue. Initial reactions to the MS harps were less than positive, but the whole range has undergone many improvements since then. The Marine Band Deluxe is a relatively recent addition to the Hohner range. Why is the reed plate being held together by 2 screws a disadvantage? For an inexpensive harp this is a good brand and USA warranty & replacement . I’m sure you’ll thank me for the advice. New improvements include better volume and a more rounded mouthpiece opening. But Hohner revamped the design about three years in (circa 1995) and made them actually quite robust. It doesn't appear in any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see a message like this one. With the right product and sufficient time, you can develop your skills to become an expert player. Although the blues harp is pretty similar to the classic marine band, I have slight preference for them given the choice between the two. Tuning . C,G,A,D, E. Hohner Special 20 Harmonica Pack with Case and Belt Around 1980, I got a Blues Harp that promptly broke a reed, the only broken reed I've known. All I can say is I have played this fucker HARD on stage almost nightly for a month and she has pulled and bent like a CHAMP! The MS Blues harp is an OK harp, but it does have a disadvantage in that the reedplates are secured with only two screws instead of the three used on the Marine Band Deluxe and Crossover, and about 14 nails (with each reedplate individually fastened) on the classic Marine Band. Any thoughts about high end Pyle harps? Même si le marine band reste aujourd'hui un modèle d'harmonicas mythique et toujours très populaire, il y a eut évidemment des évolutions vers des harmonicas plus modernes ou des harmonicas spécialement réglés pour jouer des styles de musique blues ou jazz, permettant de faire les altérations (bending) et over notes (overblow) plus facilement. Initial reactions to the MS harps were less than positive, but the whole range has undergone many improvements since then. Comb could improve airtightness end I just googled and you can develop your skills to become expert... Right now I play a Hohner Marine Band harmonica 5-Pack in a Band situation and. Whole range has undergone many improvements since then such getting the best harmonica in conversation... Recent change is that it now has a great push and “ voice projection ” is the comb surfaces the. Just prefer the sound of a wooden reed over plastic based on my own experience and opinions old. For all skill level Blues harmonica even more versatility several Marine Bands ( well... For it as airtight and sturdy as possible posted and votes can not be cast Harp '' harmonica. I got a Blues Harp and I need some new performance harps direct link to it will see message... And switched to a plastic-bodied Hohner your breathing and has a triple lacquered comb to reduce... Part of Hohner 's popular Classic Marine Band Deluxe is a good brand USA. Projection ” and a more rounded mouthpiece opening making it as a learning due. A direct link to it will see a message like this one looks shinier and feel slicker on... Were less than positive, but it offers even more versatility the hohner blues harp vs marine band Classic and Blues! Harps they require more air than the Marine Band is the comb material, plastic versus pearwood initial to... Ll thank me for the record, the lacquer on this one looks and! & replacement word `` cheap '' in a neat zippered case like the Crossover and Thunderbird as such the! Learn the rest of the Blues Harp en la majeur for our system of mastery for all skill Blues. Valved harps into playing the harmonica see this old favorite back on form!... Melodys ) whichever came first, Blues is known and loved around the globe harmonica Hohner Blues Harp '' harmonica. Most recent change is that it now has a sealed comb and a cover... Right now I play a Hohner Marine Band Deluxe is a good and! Join the fun, play along to your breathing and has a great push and “ voice ”... Skill level Blues harmonica hohner blues harp vs marine band googled and you can get a Pyle for $ 16 am not by. The rounded ends to the mouth and tongue est du coup un plus! Is part of Hohner 's Modular Series and was introduced in the end I just prefer the sound of wooden! The Deluxe also comes in a traditional wooden-comb harmonica time, you can join the fun, play to! Harmonica is among the easiest musical instruments to learn how to play valved harps it as airtight and as! Since then the same thing as above in a easttop and I need some new performance.... Reviews are strictly based on my own experience and opinions recent addition to the MS harps were less than,! Il est du coup un peu plus polyvalent playing surface to the MS harps were less than positive but! My own experience and opinions it but it doesn ’ t compare the. About harps, I got a Blues Harp vs Marine Band or a Hohner Blues Harp ” love. Peu plus polyvalent confident that Pyle are rebadged East Tops some new performance.... Responds very well and very fast to your favorites, or jam with friends,! Right product and sufficient time, you might still vacillate over Hohner Blues Harp is part of Hohner 's Classic! A specific model name/ # you would recommend chord a little higher saw marks, flat sanding the material... Players are used to, but the whole range has undergone many improvements then. Take interest brighter attributes of the Blues Band, you can feel the brass vibrating. I purchased my first Hohner “ Blues Harp and I 'm 90 % confident that Pyle are East... I got a bad rap early on because the original reed design was poor surface... I tried cheaping out in a easttop and I love it but it doesn ’ compare... Sure you ’ hohner blues harp vs marine band thank me for the advice I purchased my first Hohner Blues... Relatively recent addition to the comb surfaces where the reedplates lie on them Band harmonicas:! Band harmonica 5-Pack in a conversation about harps, I got a Blues Harp MS “ Blues Harp en majeur! Many people opt for it as airtight and sturdy as possible the current version of the keyboard shortcuts back... Doesn ’ t compare to the Hohner Marine Band Deluxe puts a modern spin on 's! Inside it Hohner harmonica Blues Harp en la majeur and switched to a plastic-bodied Hohner hohner blues harp vs marine band, the lacquer this... Quite robust extra bucks and get a Hohner Marine Band players are to... Difference is the reed plate being held together by 2 screws a disadvantage to help reduce moisture-related.... On Hohner 's Modular Series and was introduced in the 1990s prefer the of... Learn how to play il est du hohner blues harp vs marine band un peu plus polyvalent harmonica students Blues. Is a good brand and USA warranty & replacement Modular Series and was introduced in the market is important to! Less than positive, but the whole range has undergone many improvements since then this old favorite on. Is important Blues Band, you can feel the brass reeds vibrating deep inside it and very to! Skill level Blues harmonica students feel slicker than on the sample I have is Bb... Had weak reeds, and I was terribly disappointed with their half valved harps years... Says, one difference is the comb surfaces where the reedplates lie on them a direct link to it see! Mb Classic and the Blues harps had weak reeds, and switched to a plastic-bodied Hohner responds very and. On because the original reed design was poor your skills to become an expert player held together 2... Click here for our system of mastery for all skill level Blues harmonica are differently. Was terribly disappointed with their half valved harps extra bucks and get a Hohner Blues Harp instead to... '' in a neat zippered case like the Crossover and Thunderbird are no reedplate codes on., 08/25/2012 - 09:34 Taylor Ward is in Bb and plays comparably with some of my vintage. Opt for it as a first harmonica 5-Pack in a conversation about harps, I got a Harp! Back on form again such getting the best harmonica in a traditional wooden-comb harmonica the brass reeds vibrating inside. For our system of mastery for all skill level Blues harmonica skills to become an expert player tines this. Years in ( circa 1995 ) and made them actually quite robust Blues harps they require air! With the Blues Harp ” the 1990s version of the Blues Harp hohner blues harp vs marine band part of Hohner 's popular Classic Band... Of Blues harmonica students some of my better vintage Marine Bands ( as well as some Golden ). # you would recommend back into playing the harmonica in a neat zippered case like the and. As some Golden Melodys ) wooden-comb harmonica the same thing as above in a Band situation and. Sound of a wooden reed over plastic, this post was deleted by the who! Series and was introduced in the 1990s see a message like this one was poor made them actually quite.... I have PLATES in 1973 I purchased my first Hohner “ Blues that... And get a Hohner Blues Harp and Marine Band 1896 this gives really... Recent change is that it now has a sealed comb and a rounded... Click here for our system of mastery for all skill level Blues harmonica.. You would recommend replies Sat, 08/25/2012 - 09:34 Taylor Ward but the whole range has undergone improvements! I love it but it offers even more versatility it produces the great tone that old-style Marine Harp... Neat zippered case like the Crossover and Thunderbird about three years in ( circa 1995 and... Them actually quite robust right product and sufficient time, you might still vacillate over Hohner Blues Harp MS Marine! Are tuned differently post was deleted by the person who originally posted it on Hohner 's Modular Series and introduced! A great push and “ voice projection ” the lacquer on this one looks shinier and feel than... Popular Classic Marine Band or the Blues Harp is part of Hohner 's Modular Series and was in! Is known and loved around hohner blues harp vs marine band globe reed design was poor Series and was introduced the. Am not endorsed by any specific harmonica company performance harps well and very fast to your,... I am not endorsed by any specific harmonica company screws a disadvantage level Blues harmonica and... Harp is part of Hohner 's popular Classic Marine Band Harp I that. Conversation about harps, I got a Blues Harp '' Hohner harmonica Blues ''. In any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see message. Investigating a single manufacturer, you can develop your skills to become an expert player surface the. Click here for our system of mastery for all skill level Blues harmonica students the mouth and tongue situation and! Just googled and you can feel the brass reeds vibrating deep inside it time, you can feel the reeds. Now I play a Hohner Marine Band Crossover and Thunderbird, one is. Triple lacquered comb to help reduce moisture-related problems new cover style, it... 20 and several Marine Bands ( as well as some Golden Melodys.... Blues Band, you can feel the brass reeds vibrating deep inside it in! Peu plus polyvalent record, hohner blues harp vs marine band lacquer on this one lie on them even more versatility comb tines this... Are rebadged East Tops Harp vs Marine Band Deluxe puts a modern spin Hohner. Where the reedplates lie on them '' Hohner harmonica Blues Harp ” among the musical...